In no particular order because it was hard enough to limit the list to twenty.
- I Heard the Bells by Sarah McClachlan
- Straw Against the Chill by Kathy Mattea
- When My Heart Finds Christmas by Harry Connick Jr
- I Wonder As I Wonder by Keri Noble
- Love is Christmas Sara Bareilles
- God Is With Us by Casting Crowns
- Celebrate Me Home by Kenny Loggins
- Down in Yon Forest by Twila Paris
- Who Comes This Night? by James Taylor
- Peace at Last by Hem
- Follow the Shepherd Home by Mindy Smith
- Let It Fall by Over the Rhine (also My Father’s Body)
- Gold and Green by Sugarland
- The Wexford Carol by Alison Kraus, Yo-Yo Ma and others
- You Make It Feel Like Christmas by Neil Diamond
- God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen by Barenaked Ladies & Sarah McLachlan
- O Come O Come Emmanuel/Mercy Street by Simple Gifts with Billy McLaughlin
- Driving Home for Christmas by Chris Rea
- Waiting for Saint Nick by Larry Murant
- I’ll Be Home for Christmas by Jaci Velasquez
This started out as a top ten list but proved to be impossible. This is an amazing collection of newer songs or arrangements. Thank you!